Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (2024)

Jamie Forster may have received "exceptionally good" farm gate milk prices over the last three years, but he is still giving up dairy farming.

"It's just the wear and tear. It's seven days a week, and it's quite stressful," he said.

"And you're dealing with the environment, which you can't control."

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (1)

He is not alone.

Around the turn of the century there were 7,409 Victorian dairy businesses. There are now 2,796.

Last year in Victoria, Australia's biggest milk producing state, 8 per cent of its dairy farmers quit the business.

"I've just been doing it for 37 years. My body and my mind has had enough," Mr Forster said.

He said none of his four children wanted to take on the dairy farm at Cohuna in north-east Victoria.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (2)

Across the nation, milk production has shrunk to its lowest level in 30 years.

This season milk's production is tipped to be nearly 3 billion litres less than the industry's peak of 11.2 billion litres in the early 2000s.

Conversely, dairy imports like butter and cheese have nearly tripled to 27 per cent over the past 22 years and are rising, according to Dairy Australia.

Millennium drought starts dairy exodus

Mr Forster took over his parent's farm in 2001.

The 12-year millennium drought hit soon after, which he described as "pretty tough".

"We had to work out which bills we were going to pay, especially just starting out as a young fella," Mr Forster said.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (3)

He draws irrigation water from the Murray River and drought conditions often mean low or no water allocations to those with permanent water licences.

With the federal government reviving water buybacks under the Murray-Darling Basin Plan, Mr Forster is worried about the next dry spell.

"When the next drought comes, there'll be a lot of farmers leave the industry," he said.

"A lot of older ones are just hanging in there."

Mr Forster said the decline in dairy farming had "definitely taken its toll" on his community, with fewer people working in the industry.

"Our local tennis club have been going for over 100 years, but it finally finished up last year … couldn't keep going," he said.

Dairy crisis sparks change

In Victoria's south-west, United Dairy Farmers of Victoria president Bernie Free was also concerned about the industry's decline.

He said many dairy farmers were still recovering financially from the 2016 crisis when big milk processors retrospectively slashed the farm gate milk price and clawed back money already paid.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (4)

A mandatory code of conduct for milk processors now required them to offer a minimum price to farmers for the duration of their milk contracts.

Mr Free said farmers were still wary and it was becoming hard to attract the next generation to the industry.

"The young people aren't as keen to come into an industry that's not guaranteed on price," he said.

"Costs have skyrocketed, land prices have doubled in some areas, so the return on the effort and the investment is just not there."

The Australian Dairy Products Federation, which represents processors, has warned farmers should prepare for a price cut next season because Australia's milk price is 30 per cent higher than global competitors.

But Mr Free said a decent milk price was essential to drive profitability and on-farm investment, which was key to growing milk production.

He said farmers were going to produce less milk if the price dropped.

"If we don't have dairy farms that are profitable, and making a return on the investment, you won't have people investing in the industry," Mr Free said.

A 'significant period of transformation'

Dairy analyst Michael Harvey said farm labour problems, the rising cost of farmland, floods, drought and other international factors, were creating an uncertain future for the industry.

"We're seeing the Australian dairy industry go through a significant period of transformation," he said.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (5)

Mr Harvey said a stable milk pool was essential for the manufacturing sector, and numerous expensive factories in Victoria were capable of processing much larger milk volumes to compete with imports.

But 10 Australian dairy factories have closed in the past 18 months and last month the Lactalis factory at Echuca in the state's north announced it would also shut.

"That can have a huge impact on communities because these dairy companies in those communities are big employers," Mr Harvey said.

Young dairy farmer invests big

However, some dairy farmers still say there is a profit to be made.

In Victoria's south-east, Leongatha South farmer Callum Moscript has nearly finished a $5 million milking and calving shed to update his 60-year-old facility currently in use.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (6)

"It allows us to scale and grow and expand our business," he said.

"I think there's a huge future for dairy in South Gippsland and Victoria."

As well as new sheds, in the past five years the Moscript family has bought more land and nearly doubled their herd to 550 cows.

While costs were nearly double the original estimate, Mr Moscript said the new dairy meant they could triple the number of cows milked an hour with "a third of the labour", and better monitor cow health and production.

"The yard can hold 1,000 cows," he said.

"People think I'm crazy for putting a yard in that big, but watch me."

He hoped the farm gate milk price remained at a level to make it all work.

"We don't know how we are going to pay for it, but we just believe in dairy," Mr Moscript said.

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices (2024)

FAQs

Why Aussie dairy farmers are leaving the industry in droves despite 'exceptionally good' milk prices? ›

Rising production costs, workforce difficulties, and climate concerns have rippling effects on Australia's dairy farmers' viability. The Australian dairy sector has faced numerous challenges over the past decade, including drought, financial crisis, rising farmland prices, and ongoing labor shortages.

Why dairy farmers across America are dumping their milk? ›

Processing plants in the Midwest have run out of capacity at a time when cows are making more milk than ever before. There's more milk than ever in the US but nowhere left to process it, forcing farmers across the Upper Midwest to pour the excess dairy down the drain.

Why is there a shortage of milk in Australia? ›

The national dairy herd has been in decline. And dairy farmers received record high prices in 2023 for their milk because Australia's total milk production was falling. It follows then that Australia had record dairy imports in the past two years, as outlined in a Rabobank report in February.

Why are milk prices so low in Australia? ›

The Australian Dairy Products Federation says this year's lower farm gate milk price has been set to preserve the viability of the dairy industry. The federation, representing dairy processors, pointed to the flood of imported dairy products that followed several years of record high milk prices.

Why are American dairy farmers struggling? ›

80% of U.S. dairy farmers are struggling with financial stability. Market volatility and fluctuating milk prices impact profitability. Input costs, such as corn and soybean meal, comprise nearly 50% of production expenses and are rising.

What is causing milk shortage? ›

Dairy farmers struggled to immediately shift to supplying supermarkets instead of foodservice providers, and as a result many had to dump out their milk supplies. Industry experts aren't expecting the same situation here, even though the shortage is upending certain operations.

Why is dairy farming on downfall? ›

A combination of poor industry regulation, bad policy, price fluctuations in the market, and a lower demand for dairy have all contributed to dairy's decline.

What are the main dairy farming problems in Australia? ›

The Challenges Facing the Australian Dairy IndustryAustralian dairy farmers have endured a tough few years: disparity in market bargaining power; price transparency issues; exposure to recently volatile global markets; and the impact of drought are just some of the recent issues farmers have faced.

What is the future of the dairy industry in Australia? ›

Australian dairy farmers are forecast to produce around 4.6 billion litres in the second half of 2024. This is on par with the 4.62 billion litres produced from July to December 2023, but 4.5 per cent below average. The number of farmers exiting the dairy industry will continue to slow down through 2024.

Where does most of Australia's milk come from? ›

80% percent of Australia's milk production occurs in the higher rainfall areas along the southern and eastern coastlines, in the states of Victoria, South Australia and Tasmania.

How much do Australian farmers get paid for milk? ›

The 2022/23 season saw a continuation of historically high farmgate milk prices (and high milk costs), with strong competition for milk amongst processors leading to Australian dairy farmers receiving an average of A$9.80/kg MS (US$52 per 100kg of milk).

Why is butter so expensive in Australia? ›

Despite having a large domestic dairy industry, Australia is a net importer of butter and last year imported a record 47,500 tonnes. Rabobank's senior dairy analyst, Michael Harvey, said there was a range of supply and demand issues pushing global butter prices to "eye-watering levels".

Why is Australian milk so good? ›

Australian milk is sourced and produced locally. It travels from the farm to the factory where it is pasteurised (heated to destroy any harmful bacteria) and hom*ogenised (mixed for a consistent texture and taste). There really is a milk to suit everyone's needs.

Do cows enjoy being milked? ›

Individual cows may find milking either positively or negatively reinforcing, but overall, the motivation to be milked is weak. Food is significantly more rewarding than milking and likely to be a necessary incentive to attract cows to an AMS.

Where does the US get most of its dairy? ›

Farm Milk Production

The top five milk production States in 2023 were California, Wisconsin, Idaho, Texas, and New York. Collectively, these 5 States produced more than 50 percent of the U.S. annual milk supply.

Why are so many dairy farms closing? ›

After earning record-high milk prices in 2022, dairy farmers have seen their earnings plummet in recent months, with more operations struggling to stay in business and some closing their doors for good. Their plight has prompted comparisons to the 2009 economic crisis that forced droves of dairies into bankruptcy.

Why are people dumping milk in stores? ›

Teens are dumping milk on store floors to protest the 'destructive' dairy industry. The latest environmentalist trend is here: pouring out milk in grocery stores.

What is the controversy with Dairy Farmers of America? ›

Dairy Farmers of America in 2015 agreed to pay $50 million to resolve a class action from farmers in northeastern United States accusing the cooperative of conspiring to suppress milk prices. The cooperative in 2013 settled a similar case for $140 million involving farmers in the southeastern United States.

Why milk production has dropped? ›

Possible causes of low supply

Nearly all babies need to feed at least 8 to 12 times in 24 hours. Your baby does not feed effectively at the breast. You have started using formula milk as well as breastfeeding. You have had breast surgery that is affecting your milk supply.

Why did the government push drinking milk? ›

Beginning in earnest after World War II, the US government, schools, and doctors had all promoted milk as a nutritious drink, a necessary component of a healthy diet, especially for children.

Top Articles
Amazon Aurora, Redshift, DynamoDBのワークロード別性能を比較する - Qiita
Photos: See the Northern lights from rare solar storm
Craigslist Home Health Care Jobs
Craigslist St. Paul
Chris Provost Daughter Addie
Enrique Espinosa Melendez Obituary
Windcrest Little League Baseball
Rabbits Foot Osrs
Craglist Oc
Collision Masters Fairbanks
Wells Fargo Careers Log In
Florida (FL) Powerball - Winning Numbers & Results
Cranberry sauce, canned, sweetened, 1 slice (1/2" thick, approx 8 slices per can) - Health Encyclopedia
Goldsboro Daily News Obituaries
Aces Fmc Charting
Summoner Class Calamity Guide
Nj State Police Private Detective Unit
111 Cubic Inch To Cc
Clear Fork Progress Book
Kringloopwinkel Second Sale Roosendaal - Leemstraat 4e
Great Clips Grandview Station Marion Reviews
Craigslist St. Cloud Minnesota
Defending The Broken Isles
Bidrl.com Visalia
Ou Football Brainiacs
Garden Grove Classlink
Safeway Aciu
Lcsc Skyward
Lesson 1.1 Practice B Geometry Answers
Insidious 5 Showtimes Near Cinemark Southland Center And Xd
Darknet Opsec Bible 2022
2487872771
Abga Gestation Calculator
Craigslist Maryland Baltimore
Gas Prices In Henderson Kentucky
Teenage Jobs Hiring Immediately
Lichen - 1.17.0 - Gemsbok! Antler Windchimes! Shoji Screens!
The Best Carry-On Suitcases 2024, Tested and Reviewed by Travel Editors | SmarterTravel
Omnistorm Necro Diablo 4
Craigslist Mount Pocono
Muziq Najm
Blasphemous Painting Puzzle
Nearest Ups Office To Me
Paperless Employee/Kiewit Pay Statements
Mid America Irish Dance Voy
60 X 60 Christmas Tablecloths
Flappy Bird Cool Math Games
Senior Houses For Sale Near Me
Best Haircut Shop Near Me
A Man Called Otto Showtimes Near Cinemark Greeley Mall
Upcoming Live Online Auctions - Online Hunting Auctions
San Pedro Sula To Miami Google Flights
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 6058

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.